Ontario Budget: Federal-Provincial Relations
My post on the night after Ontarioâ€™s budget hit the key features. However, the budget had a couple of other interesting aspects from a federal-provincial perspective.
Some progressive voices trumpeted the provincial budgetâ€™s allocation of $63.5 million annually to replace discontinued federal funding for childcare spaces. While the Ontario government finally made the right decision on this file, it got way too much credit.
First, $63.5 million is only 0.05% of annual provincial expenditures. This funding hardly represents a major commitment to public childcare.
Second, provincial income taxes apply to the tax base defined by the federal government. Because the last federal budget slightly broadened this base by closing some tax loopholes, Ontarioâ€™s government will automatically collect an additional $81 million annually. (See Table 3 on page 167 of the provincial budget.)
Taken together, these two federal policies reduced provincial transfer revenue by $63.5 million but increased provincial tax revenue by $81 million. Should we really applaud Queenâ€™s Park for using three-quarters of its windfall tax revenue to replace the lost transfer revenue?
Only a couple of years ago, Premier McGuinty was obnoxiously demanding that Equalization be abolished. But his governmentâ€™sÂ recent budget confirms that Ontario will actually receive a billion dollars of Equalization transfers this fiscal year. So, had the federal government followed McGuintyâ€™s advice, Ontarioâ€™s deficit would now be a billion dollars larger.
McGuintyâ€™s likely retort would be that Ontario stills pays more into Equalization than it gets out. The federal government spends $14 billion annually on Equalization and collects about 40% of its revenue in Ontario. In that sense, the province pays $5.6 billion into Equalization.
However, none of that money comes from the Government of Ontario. The provinceâ€™s only â€œcontributionâ€ is that residents pay the same federal tax rates as all other Canadians.
In theory, if the federal government eliminated Equalization and cut federal taxes by a corresponding amount (e.g. another two points off the GST), the Ontario government could increase provincial revenues by occupying the tax room. But Ottawa has already slashed its taxes by more than that amount and Ontario has not occupied the tax room.
Since Queenâ€™s Park is unwilling to raise provincial taxes, the only effect of scrapping Equalization would be to reduce Ontarioâ€™s provincial revenues by a billion dollars. Fortunately, the federal government ignored McGuintyâ€™s recent demand to do that.