Main menu:

History of RPE Thought

Posts by Tag

RSS New from the CCPA

  • 2019 Federal Budget Analysis February 27, 2019
    Watch this space for response and analysis of the federal budget from CCPA staff and our Alternative Federal Budget partners. More information will be added as it is available. Commentary and Analysis  Aim high, spend low: Federal budget 2019 by David MacDonald (CCPA) Budget 2019 fiddles while climate crisis looms by Hadrian Mertins-Kirkwood (CCPA) Organizational Responses Canadian Centre for Policy […]
    Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives
  • Boots Riley in Winnipeg May 11 February 22, 2019
    Founder of the political Hip-Hop group The Coup, Boots Riley is a musician, rapper, writer and activist, whose feature film directorial and screenwriting debut — 2018’s celebrated Sorry to Bother You — received the award for Best First Feature at the 2019 Independent Spirit Awards (amongst several other accolades and recognitions). "[A] reflection of the […]
    Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives
  • CCPA-BC welcomes Emira Mears as new Associate Director February 11, 2019
    This week the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives – BC Office is pleased to welcome Emira Mears to our staff team as our newly appointed Associate Director. Emira is an accomplished communications professional, digital strategist and entrepreneur. Through her former company Raised Eyebrow, she has had the opportunity to work with many organizations in the […]
    Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives
  • Study explores media coverage of pipeline controversies December 14, 2018
    Supporters of fossil fuel infrastructure projects position themselves as friends of working people, framing climate action as antithetical to the more immediately pressing need to protect oil and gas workers’ livelihoods. And as the latest report from the CCPA-BC and Corporate Mapping Project confirms, this framing has become dominant across the media landscape. Focusing on pipeline […]
    Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives
  • Study highlights ‘uncomfortable truth’ about racism in the job market December 12, 2018
    "Racialized workers in Ontario are significantly more likely to be concentrated in low-wage jobs and face persistent unemployment and earnings gaps compared to white employees — pointing to the “uncomfortable truth” about racism in the job market, according to a new study." Read the Toronto Star's coverage of our updated colour-coded labour market report, released […]
    Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives
Progressive Bloggers

Meta

Recent Blog Posts

Posts by Author

Recent Blog Comments

The Progressive Economics Forum

McGuinty on Equalization: A Reality Check

For a while, the Ontario Premier was looking quite reasonable in his dispute with the federal government. As Jim Flaherty charged that Ontario’s economic woes reflected a lack of provincial corporate tax cuts, Dalton McGuinty correctly responded that a lower rate of tax on profits would entail a large fiscal cost and provide little assistance to Ontario’s currently unprofitable manufacturing sector.

Unfortunately, the Ontario Premier seems to have changed his tune. His new line is that he would cut corporate taxes if only the federal government would scrap Equalization.

This line seems like a diversion from the debate that should be happening in Ontario about how to use provincial procurement, targeted tax credits, electricity policy, etc. to revitalize the ailing manufacturing sector. The focus on Equalization also distracts attention from federal policies, including trade and monetary policy, that have actually hurt Ontario manufacturing.

In criticizing Equalization, McGuinty speaks of the federal government taking $20 billion out of Ontario’s economy. Since the entire Equalization program costs about $15 billion, this figure deserves some scrutiny.

In 2005, the most recent year for which the relevant Statistics Canada figures are available, the federal government raised about 42% of its revenues in Ontario ($91 billion out of $216 billion). Therefore, the people of Ontario pay about $6 billion into Equalization, which equals about 1% of provincial GDP.

As far as I can tell, $20 billion is approximately the difference between total federal revenues from Ontario ($91 billion) and total federal spending in Ontario ($70 billion). Less than one-third of this difference constitutes Ontario taxpayers’ contribution to Equalization.

The remaining two-thirds mostly reflects the extent to which Ontario was more prosperous than other provinces in 2005. On average, Ontarians paid more federal taxes and qualified for fewer federal benefits than other Canadians.  In 2005, the overall federal surplus and federal spending outside Canada also contributed about $3 billion to the gap between federal revenues and expenditures in Ontario.

I suspect that the deterioration of Ontario’s economy since 2005 has narrowed this gap. But it remains because Ontario is still richer than most of the rest of the country.

Ontario’s per-capita GDP has fallen behind the three oil-rich provinces: Newfoundland, Saskatchewan, and Alberta (with combined populations of 5 million). However, in 2007, Ontario’s per-capita GDP exceeded every other province (with combined populations of 15 million). Continued redistribution from Ontario taxpayers to these other provincial governments hardly seems unreasonable.

Even if the federal government took McGuinty’s advice and eliminated Equalization, it would not automatically increase the Government of Ontario’s fiscal capacity. If Equalization and the federal taxes that finance it disappeared, Ontario after-tax incomes and profits would rise by about $6 billion. Conceivably, the Ontario government could then raise provincial tax rates enough to collect this additional $6 billion. However, this scenario does not support McGuinty’s apparent suggestion that killing Equalization would permit lower provincial tax rates.

UPDATE (May 12): Not surprisingly, the National Post has praised McGuinty’s call to scrap Equalization.

Enjoy and share:

Write a comment





Related articles