Main menu:

History of RPE Thought

Posts by Tag

RSS New from the CCPA

  • Kate McInturff's Prebudget Presentation to FINA, 2017 July 30, 2018
    Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives
  • In loving memory of Kate McInturff July 30, 2018
    On July 27, 2018, CCPA Senior Researcher Kate McInturff passed away. The CCPA mourns the devastating loss of our colleague and friend. Kate will be remembered as a feminist trailblazer in public policy and gender-based research. Our hearts go out to her family. Kate’s colleagues, collaborators, and countless organizations across Canada are stronger because of her […]
    Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives
  • Debunking myths about proportional representation July 25, 2018
    This fall, British Columbians will get to vote on whether we want a new electoral system for our province. What an incredible opportunity. Between October 22 and November 30, BC voters will be able to vote in a mail-in referendum. The ballot will look something like this: We at the CCPA-BC are big fans of […]
    Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives
  • Canada’s fossil-fuelled pensions June 22, 2018
    The British Columbia Investment Management Corporation is the steward of BC’s public pensions, but bankrolls companies whose current business models exceed the climate change targets agreed to in the Paris Agreement to which Canada is a signatory. The pensions of over 500,000 British Columbians and assets worth $135 billion are managed by the Corporation—-one of Canada's largest […]
    Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives
  • Imagine a Winnipeg...2018 Alternative Municipal Budget June 18, 2018
    Climate change; stagnant global economic growth; political polarization; growing inequality.  Our city finds itself dealing with all these issues, and more at once. The 2018 Alternative Municipal Budget (AMB) is a community response that shows how the city can deal with all these issues and balance the budget.
    Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives
Progressive Bloggers

Meta

Recent Blog Posts

Posts by Author

Recent Blog Comments

The Progressive Economics Forum

Rochon on the Bank of Canada’s Decision to Lower the Rate of Interest

Louis-Philippe Rochon—who now blogs for CBC—argues that almost nobody had been expecting the Bank of Canada’s recent decision to lower the rate of interest.

His post can be found here.

Follow him on Twitter @Lprochon.

Enjoy and share:

Comments

Comment from Ron Waller
Time: January 28, 2015, 7:37 am

Just read a related column by Neil Macdonald in the CBC which was founded on hysteria and ignorance. It’s got the people all riled up. (Kind of like saying the Russians have just launched a nuclear strike against North America: the mass media version of yelling fire in a theater.)

I think Professor Rochon should try to explain to the people in a CBC column how money actually works. (I would suggest trying to explain it to Mr. Macdonald, but that would seem pointless. He interviewed economists before writing his dimwitted diatribe.)

Here’s my humble comment; (just thought I’d share):

This column is largely nonsense. The money supply grows with the economy, at an exponential rate. The US, for example, printed “state money” which only makes up 15% of its total money supply. If one looks at the trend line, a constant rate of growth, you can trace money supply growth back years or decades, and it was actually BELOW trend during QE.

Money won’t suddenly become valueless. It doesn’t work that way. The only way the value of money can erode is through inflation. It can only loose its value entirely through hyper-inflation. (With deflation, money gains in value, but this causes real debt — or debt burden — to increase.)

The inflation rate is tied to the state of the economy. Low inflation (or deflation,) bad economic performance. Rising inflation, an overheating economy. The central banks put a limit on inflation — 2%. (Which is actually too low because inflation is reined in with recession and high unemployment. It’s largely the reason the economy collapsed: first the dot-com bust; then the housing/derivatives bust.)

The real problem with printing money is that it is trickle-down supply-side economics. It’s helicopter money dropped on the heads of rich bankers. It’s a lousy form of stimulus, which is why the Western economy is in the midst of a 7-year slump. (At least: if one looks at GDP growth, it’s more like 15 years.) In the (successful) post-war Keynesian era, stimulus was demand-side, trickle-up, putting wealth more directly in the hands of the people. This created modern living standards (what’s left of them.)

Comment from Louis-Philippe Rochon
Time: January 28, 2015, 8:01 am

Do you have a link to the MacDonald column?

Comment from Ron Waller
Time: January 28, 2015, 8:07 am

BTW, another way helicopter money is inferior to fiscal stimulus: house price inflation. This always ends badly.

According to one index I say in a Krugman blog, real house prices are over 200% (when they tend to stay at 100% in the long term.)

Speculation and people using huge lines of credit to do renovations, drive the price up. Eventually what goes up must come down.

Although it’s pretty to think your $150,000 house is suddenly worth $300,000, it usually doesn’t do any good. Want to move into another house, it costs $300,000. So nothing gained.

Of course people (baby boomers) think they can sell their houses and retire to Mexico. But what happens when a large demographic starts selling off their homes to collect their retirement savings? The bubble bursts (if it didn’t already.)

The US bubble was founded on fraud, which is why it collapsed so fast. Canada will be more like Japan, whose housing bubble didn’t go out with a bang, but a 15-year bear market. In the first 15 years, prices rose from 100% to 220%. 15 years later, they dropped back down to 100%.

In the meantime, the Japanese economy suffered a 20-year (and counting) slump. Nominal GDP is actually lower now than it was in 1995! And the country amassed 220% GDP in government debt.

The real problem with their debt is that they have too low of a tax rate. Tax revenues are 28.6% GDP, when the average of the top 25 economies is 35.6%.

Now the country is listening to New Classical crackpots who say tax consumption and cut corporate taxes to spur growth. This move, of course, put their economy back in recession.

For the record, in the post-war era, we managed very high debt with big spending and high taxes on the rich. It puts money in the hands of the people where it does some good, creating incredible GDP growth (which allowed governments to pay down most of their debt/GDP.)

The only alternative to returning to the Keynesian system is watching civilization collapse. It’s up to the people to manage their world. Insatiably greedy — and utterly corrupt — businessmen sure aren’t gong to do it.

Comment from Ron Waller
Time: January 28, 2015, 8:09 am

It was posted this morning:

ANALYSIS | The spreading alchemy of central bank money-printing

Write a comment





Related articles