(The following is something I’ve prepared for the next issue of CUPE’s Economy at Work, a popular economics quarterly publication I produce.)
In his annual Economic and Fiscal Update (EFU), finance minister Joe Oliver told Canadians that while the federal government will finally record a surplus next year after seven years of deficits, we canâ€™t expect the economy to grow much faster than the slow growth weâ€™ve experienced since the financial crisis, with economic growth expected to average just 2.4% over the next four years.
Economic growth in this recovery is a third slower than in the recoveries of the 80s and 90s while job and wage growth has also been dismal. And despite all the spending cuts theyâ€™ve made, we also canâ€™t expect the federal government to have much extra money because the additional tax cuts theyâ€™ve promised are eating up a lot of the surplus.
If we have a balanced budget and federal taxes have been cut to the lowest share of the economy in 70 years, why is out economy growing so slowly? It certainly isnâ€™t because interest rates are low: instead theyâ€™re close to historic lows, so low they could fuel another asset boom and bust. It isnâ€™t because businesses lack money to invest: they have a record $600 billion of excess cash they arenâ€™t investing in the economy. It isnâ€™t because weâ€™re lacking labour: there are over 1.2 million officially unemployed with hundreds of thousands more underemployed.
So if everything is in place according to the Conservativesâ€™ economic ideologyâ€”balanced budgets, low taxes, low interest rates, corporations flush with cash, excess labour, free trade, low wage growthâ€”why does the economy suck?
The answer is right under Joe Oliverâ€™s nose, in his departmentâ€™s publications and media releasesâ€”and is illustrated with the chart below.
In his Economic and Fiscal Update (and in many of his recent public announcements) Oliver boasts about how much the Harper government has cut federal government spending and how much theyâ€™ve cut taxes. The EFU emphasizes how theyâ€™ve balanced the budget by cutting program spending â€œFederal direct program spending has declined for four consecutive years, a trend that has not been achieved in decadesâ€ while also cutting taxes by billions, including through income splitting. In fact the EFU illustrates (on page 63) that under the Harper governmentâ€™s plans, federal program expenses as a share of GDP will fall to an historic low.
But the following chart (based on â€œeconomic multipliersâ€ from Finance Canada and two highly respected private sector economic analysis firms) shows that public spending has a much stronger impact on the economy than tax cuts do. This means that cutting public spending while also cutting taxes will lead to slower economic growth, higher unemployment and lower wage growth.
For instance, if the federal government cuts $1 billion from health care and social services, it will lead to a loss of an estimated 18,000 direct and indirect jobs and a decline in the economy of $2 billion.Â Â Meanwhile an income tax cut of $1 billion will only generate an estimated 6,000 jobs and boost the economy by $1.3 billion.Â Â So if the government cuts spending by $1 billion while also cutting income taxes by $1 billion, it will lead to a net loss of -12,000 jobs and a net decline in the economy of -$0.7 billion.
Investments in childcare have the strongest impact in terms of jobs and one of the strongest in terms of economic growth while corporate tax cuts have the weakest impact.Â When the economy is suffering from deficient demand, as it is now, these differences are magnified even more than the multipliers below show.
Our economy doesnâ€™t suck because we suck. Â Canadians are skilled, hardworking, conscientious and productive (and, yes, polite too).Â Our economy sucks because our federal governmentâ€™s economic policies suckâ€”and it just mightÂ be time to do something about it.
- Lessons from the Reagan Era on Managing Twin Deficits (February 14th, 2017)
- Federal Income Support for Low-Income Seniors (August 29th, 2016)
- Central Agencies in Canada (August 8th, 2016)
- Ten things to know about the 2016-17 Alberta budget (May 3rd, 2016)
- Mixed bag for EI in Budget 2016 (March 23rd, 2016)