Job Vacancies vs. Unemployment
Progressive economists have advocated expansionary fiscal and monetary policies to boost demand and create jobs, given the high rate of unemployment. By contrast, employers and conservative commentators complain of unfilled vacancies and labour shortages, emphasizing policies to increase labour supply and labour mobility.
Todayâ€™s new Statistics Canada survey of job vacancies sheds fresh light on this debate. The finding that â€œthere were 3.3 unemployed people in Canada for every job vacancyâ€ confirms that the main problem is a lack of jobs, not alleged disincentives to work or barriers to labour mobility. In other words, policymakers should focus on the demand side rather than on the supply side.
In Alberta and Saskatchewan, provinces supposedly plagued by labour shortages, there were three unemployed workers for every two vacancies. Even in mining, oil and gas â€“ the sector with by far the highest rate of job vacancy â€“ unemployment exceeded vacancies. These figures debunk the view that the solution is simply to prod workers to move west.